Grammar Info

N3 Lesson 1: 8/22

べきではないShould not, Must not , Ought not to

する → すべきではない・するべきではない

Structure

Verb + べき + ではない
Verb + べき + じゃない

［い］Adjective + くある + べき + ではない
［い］Adjective + くある + べき + じゃない

［な］Adjective + である + べき + ではない
［な］Adjective + である + べき + じゃない

Noun + である + べき + ではない
Noun + である + べき + じゃない

Details

  • Register

    Standard

  • Rare Kanji

    可き

About べきではない

As an extension of the auxiliary verb べき, that is partnered with verbs to convey 'ought to do (A)', べきではない (or べきじゃない) highlights the opposite, and means 'ought not to (A)', 'should not (A)', or 'must not (A)'. Just like べき, it is quite strong, and implies that doing (A) would be considered improper/incorrect.

べきではない (or べきじゃない) will be paired with the plain (non-past) form of a verb.

Caution

As with all other structures that use では, は may be omitted. However, as the presence of は strengthens the ない, the overall phrase will sound a little bit weaker without it.

  • 一人(ひとり)であの山(やま)に行(い)くべきではない。
    You must not go to that mountain alone.
  • 人(ひと)を傷(きず)つけるような事(こと)を言(い)うべきでない。
    You ought not to say anything that could hurt a person's feelings.

Fun Fact

The combination of する and べき is a rare grammatical exception in Japanese, in which two forms are both considered equally correct. Due to this, either するべき, or すべき may be used.

  • テストの前(まえ)に徹夜(てつや)をするべきではない。
    You ought not to stay up all night before a test.
  • くだらないことで警察(けいさつ)に電話(でんわ)すべきではない。
    You must not call the cops for something trivial.

Examples

--:--

    あなた一人(ひとり)だけで決(き)める可(べ)きではない。

    You should not decide alone.

    腐(くさ)っている食(た)べ物(もの)を食(た)べる可(べ)きではない。

    You shouldn't eat food that is rotten.

    禁煙(きんえん)場所(ばしょ)では、タバコを吸(す)う可(べ)きではない。

    You should not smoke in places that are non-smoking.

    大(たい)したことないよ。心配(しんぱい)をする可(べ)きではない。

    It's not important. You shouldn't worry about it.

    人(ひと)が嫌(いや)がることをする可(べ)きではない。

    You should not do things people dislike.

  • Get more example sentences!

    Premium users get access to 12 example sentences on all Grammar Points.

Self-Study Sentences

Study your own way!

Add sentences and study them alongside Bunpro sentences.

べきではない – Grammar Discussion

Most Recent Replies (4 in total)

  • Pushindawood

    Pushindawood

    @pampel Thank you for your question. While は can be omitted, less emphasis is placed on the negation with its absence, and answers with its inclusion (or じゃない) are generally more common in modern Japanese. I have included a note about this on the grammar page and have added でない to answers that throw hints/warnings rather than marking you wrong. Cheers!

  • wrt7MameLZE33wlmpCAV

    wrt7MameLZE33wlmpCAV

    One thing that has always confused me with this grammar point is why it’s べきではない instead of ないべきだ. To my English brain, it’s the latter that seems correct, as opposed to the former (“not obliged to” vs. “obliged to not”). I understand that it’s wrong, but I don’t understand why.

    Anyone have any insights?

  • Daru

    Daru

    It’s actually super simple: べき is an auxiliary verb that comes from べし’s attributive form.
    It sounds advanced, but it’s basically saying that it’s a verb that got turned into a noun-like word for better connection in the language. (And hence, why it’s negated as じゃない/ではない)

    With this in mind, it’s just a matter of the language being in order to function.
    Verb + Auxiliary べき + Negation of the Auxiliary ではない

    You can’t negate what you haven’t established for negation!
    ないべきだ would translate as “Don’t must.”

Got questions about べきではない? Join us to discuss, ask, and learn together!

Join the Discussion